Anyone rate my Dr. Who sigs?

[Luke]

Hey, I've been messing around with macromedia and with Sam's help i've made a few experimental Dr. Who sigs. Can you just say which one you prefer and why, it could help me out with what style works best.

Cheers.

http://i74.photobucket.com/albums/i274/01lfitchett/Drwho_Sig.png

http://i74.photobucket.com/albums/i274/01lfitchett/Drwho_Notletthishappen.png

http://i74.photobucket.com/albums/i274/01lfitchett/Drwho_fire-ice-rage.png

If anyone uses the program, tips and guidelines would be appreciated.

Thanks, Luke

[Pveatherfall]

Absolutely the third one is my fave of the three. David Tennat is one of those extraordinary people who can put his emotion into his eyes. You chose a great pic for that one. I liked the font choice too. Did you try messing around with the arrangement of the words on that one or did just go straight with one column?

Otherwise - the first one was kinda cool. I liked seeing him from torso up. Gave him definition. The second one though. The font/color seemed wrong somehow. I had a harder time reading it. The words matched well with the pic though.

I don't know much about sig making though - hope that helped at least.

[Sam]

I really like the first one, i love how it came out.
The effect you used on the image takes the seemingly simple signature and makes it interesting and really good looking.
The second one, again i think the image is brilliant, the effect on it is amazing and suits the concerned feel of the sig. Though i think the font of the text could probably be improved, maybe something a bit creepier.
As for the last one, again love the image use, as Pveatherfall said, Tennant has such skill with emotion in his eyes. And i think this reflects it, all i can suggest is possibly adjusting the font, not sure how, just needs a tiny tweak.
I'll also say that i think the idea of that little "Luke" signature in the bottom left corner of each is truly inspired.

All round great job mate.