Ultimate Rating Thread...TWO!

Kiggs · Jan 21, 2005, 05:12 PM

The old one was getting pretty long, and I also wanted to remake it, as I'm just like that.

Anyway...basic rules of the thread-

Don't rate someone's graphics TWICE. If they change it, go ahead, but otherwise, wait for someone else.

You can rate their Signature, Avatar, and User picture, though you're not obligated to rate all three.

Please rate from 1-10.

Give a reason why, don't just type some numbers.

And finally...be tactful. If it sucks, don't say "it sucks." Tell them what they can work on.

---
I'm going to go ahead and rate Flare's from the last thread.

Sig- 8.9/10 ...Very busy, but well done.

Av- 9/10 ...Looks good.

Usercard- 7/10, but only because Cloud looks like Gourry in it.

Minion · Jan 21, 2005, 05:16 PM

Sig: 9.5/10. I like the lightsaber and all, but if everything around it were a bit darker, it would be a lot better.

Av: 9/10

Card: who is that? 8.5/10

***BZero*** · Jan 23, 2005, 05:52 PM

Sig: I like it, but I think it would be better without the text. Near the top right, it looks like the image is just kind of "cut off", if you know what I mean. And the hand looks kinda... f*cked up. Is it supposed to look like that? Eh, I'll give it a... 7/10

Av: ...It's a pic of some guy... with an ugly green font. 4/10 =/

Card: I have no idea who that is, and there's not much to rate, really. 5/10

Xeonix · Jan 25, 2005, 11:46 AM

Avatar: Pretty cool. I thinks it needs a border that will match it. 8/10

Sig: Pretty...red. o.o Needs a border though. Better change the color of your name cause it can't be seen cause of the sig's color. 8/10

Card: Funny

7/10

Lord DB · Jan 25, 2005, 11:51 AM

Flare - re-rated, as a result of new graphics.

Avi: Hmm. Gundam Wing? Ahh, well, nice, colourful, bright. 9/10

Sig #1: Is that still Gundam? Either way, it suits your avi well, and is as bright. Im not too keen on the text, but... 9/10

Sig #2: Tough one. Somewhere in the A list of graphics I think. Perhaps a bit better, but I really must learn these things. 9/10

Card: I thnk I've already rated it.

**Dr. Flux** · Jan 26, 2005, 08:16 AM

Avatar- Default animated 5/10

Signature- It's not presented very well. It looks uneven with the image placement and text placement. And the brown border, forgive me for saying this, makes it look ugly with the black.

It could be improved with the underlined text and the actual font of the text. Also as I said previously, placement. 6/10

Card- That pictures pretty funny.

But you should resize it so it fits properly.

Xeonix · Jan 26, 2005, 09:08 AM

I forgot whether I've rated Double M's sig, hmm...if I didn't might as well rate it.

Avatar: Errr, I don't see one.

Sig: Very pretty, it also matches your card. 9/10

Card: Another very neat, like the red and white combination. 8.5/10

Zanelli · Jan 26, 2005, 10:35 AM

Flare your graphic skills have greatly improved since I left.

Avi: 9/10 I love the way you've used the white text down the middle and lined affect.

Sig (I shall only do the top one): also 9/10. It works well with your Avatar and the colours work well.

Mikayla · Jan 26, 2005, 04:51 PM

Avatar: Can't see the text, but that could just be me when it pops up. Though I love your colors. 8/10

Sig: Nifty, but I'm not a big fan of it. 6/10

Sig: I like it. The colors are cool and Sephiroth goes well with it. 8/10

Card: Little cramped in. But its cool. 5/10

Thief · Jan 26, 2005, 08:44 PM

Signature Pictures: They look so similar that I don't want to do it twice. Well made, but a little plain. [left-handed compliment] It suits you, though [left-handed compliment]. 8/10.

Avatar: Simplicity, looks like it's in widescreen. I don't like widescreen... 8/10.

Card: I love the quote, I feel like that a lot. The picture looks like it's messily, professionally made by the artist. 9/10.

Zanelli · Feb 1, 2005, 09:40 AM

Okay.

Your Avi is a quite pixeled and needs a boarder; it's still a good attempt. 6/10

Your sig is a little large and the text is fuzzy. I think if you’d cropped it so the top and bottom go off the edge it would have looked better and a thin white boarder one pixel in from the edge would look good. 5/10

Sum Mors · Feb 1, 2005, 02:31 PM

Sig: I'm not exactly knowing who that is in the back, but it doesn't matter. The cutting looks farely well done. His nose looks a little funny though.

I'm not a fan of the scanline thing, but it is done well. I don't see any problems.

The picture quality on the front picture doesn't match the quality of the background picture, and the color is a little off.

The font is nicely blended.

8/10.

Avatar: A little hard to read, but it is clean. 7/10.

Card: It is sized wrong, and a little abstract. Meh. 4/10 from me.

**Dr. Flux** · Feb 5, 2005, 03:14 AM

Signature: Alright, I've kinda grown too used to it, so it looks boring now. 8/10

Av: Is still good. 9/10

You should change set soon.

Kiggs · Feb 5, 2005, 05:04 AM

Linda is a beautiful anvil. I wish you well in your married life.

Av- 8/10...simply because I don't like the size. >.>

Sig- 9/10 It's simple..but I <3 simpleness. And the animation is adorable.

krikie · Feb 5, 2005, 03:51 PM

My avatar is small, I know. Problems uploading it *Sigh*

So Kiggs -

Ava: I love it. And it matches your sig, which makes me love it even more. 9.9/10

Sig- I love that too. Nice background, font, and The image blends great. 10/10

Card- I don't really like the image, and the cutting could be better

7/10