Ultimate Rating Thread...THREE!

[Kiggs]

Whoosh! Time for the third one of these. I want all of them to max out somewhere around 250 posts, and I think I should make a thing or two clear again. First of all...the normal rules.


- Definitely don't rate someone's graphic's twice. If they change their signature or avatar, feel free to again, but don't rate the same thing more than once. Give someone else a chance.

- You can rate their tag, avatar, and user-picture, though you do not have to rate all three of them.

- Please give a rating between 1-10, and give a reason why. In a tactful way, please. Give some quick advice on what they could do better, and what's good.

And now for the new rules. Oh wait. There's only one. Heh.

- If you did not make your tag and avatar, you can post in here, but please, please don't post really often. This is for designers to get quick critique, NOT a place to up your post count.


Rate away!

[krikie]

Wellllllll

Avatar: I must say that I really like this set. I like how you made it exactly half of Shiva's face. and the colors match really, really well. Love the shape and the background. MY only suggestion would be to maybe put something in the empty space? 9.5/10

Sig: Same pretty background and color scheme. The image is really nice, and I LOVE LOVE LOVE the font. Scriptina? I just love the glow on it. It really pulls it together. An amazing set. 10/10

[Derextreme]

For Krikie Set

Ava : I like the background and the border. It is both a nice combination. 9 / 10

Sig: Maybe this is not my type. 7 / 10

Card : Nice one. It is sweet and cute. 8.5 / 10

[Minion]

Av: ....what the hell? The "square-in-the-corner" is old. 8/10

Sig: Again, squares are old. That looks weird. 7/10

Card: ...meh. 7/10

Overall, I don't like it. Next time, find a set that doesn't have those crappy blocks.

[Joshi]

Minion you have changed =P.
Av: Gotta love VGCats. 8/10
Sig1: Nice background and it just adicts me. 8.5/10
Sig2: Yay Pwnt is back in town 7/10
And Ok Kiggs I will calm down.

[Derextreme]

Since I rated Dagger's before.

Minion's Set.

Ava : It is cute. Scared 8 / 10

Sig1 : This is looks like an attack that looks like any eye. 9 / 10

Sg2: It is Classic and i do not really like it. 7 / 10

[Mig]

ok.

Av. It's very hard to make anything out,,, a few numbers... maybe it's abstract art? i dunno. 7/10

Sig1. It's a car and... WTF! Strange, very... 7/10

Sig2. Oh look! something I can make out! His face looks a little squished, but that might just be me. 8/10

Card: Nice pic. The quote brings back memories. 10/10

EDIT: Just noticed I forgot the border on the sig. Please pretend it's got the same border as the avatar . I'm working on it now.

EDIT EDIT: That'll do.

[krikie]

Avatar: I can't tell what it is (even though I know) but it's pretty. 8/10

Sig: Still really doesn't look like alexander, and the font is hard to read. 6/10 Nice effects though

card: Small and scary? Ack! I don't like aliens 6/10

[Joshi]

Esp's Set as I have done Krikies.
Sig: <3 Alexander. 9/10
Av: Also Alexander. 8/10
Card: Alien 7.5/10

[Holy_Aeris]

Avy- 10/10 i like the border, the style, the colour, text and pic!!! great avy!

Siggy- 10/10 same as above^

Card- 10/10 lol i love it!!!! that is one funky cactuar!!!

[Joshi]

H_A
Av: Default 5/10
Sig: Just a pit of cut and past really. Still its a nice font. 7.5/10
Card: What happend to her on that day I wonder 6.5/10

[Kiggs]

NO. You rate the person right above you. This is NOT the "rate the person two posts above me" thread. If you have rated that persons, then DO NOT post.

What part about the rules is so hard to understand?

Feel free to skip my tag/av, and continue on from above. FOR THE LAST AND ONLY TIME.

[Mikayla]

o_o I hope you don't mind if I rate your set... kiggs..

avatar: <3 9/10
sig: I love the font. The Shiva picture is nice as well. 9/10
card: Looks like she has something up her nose 9/10

[Doodlebop]

Well, the set looks nice...But why don'tcha use your sn instead of the other one? Maybe I missed out on something, but I don't follow the logic. For this, I cut yer stuff down by a good three points.

7/10

[krikie]

Ahh, gorillaz =)

Avatar - none ..

Sig= very very very pretty background. Good cutting job, font could be placed better, but good nonetheless. 9/10

Card- That's a good song .. but it's a plain card. 5/10